jeudi, avril 27, 2006

“The President is Sleeping. You’ll Wake Him Up.”

On Saturday night, I went to a reception for some journalists which was at the home of an American diplomat, located in the extremely tony and unfamiliar neighborhoods of downtown Kinshasa. His house overlooks the river, which is amazing, and the program was nice. To get to the house, you need to go through a Presidential Guard, which can pose serious problems though Saturday was fine, because there was a US security officer there with a guest list.

As we were leaving these unfamiliar parts, we came up on another roadblock and an encampment of five hungry soldiers with machineguns. We got stopped. They detained the driver, just to empty out his wallet, and somehow got the keys to the car. Actually, even though I am unfamiliar with this area, I did recognize one of the buildings as a US residence. And there was a security guard there who came out to the street, and observed. He did not intervene, but the soldiers knew they were being watched. While they were talking to the driver, I spoke to the security officer--introduced myself, showed him my identification, asked where I was, and otherwise made small talk. The soldiers kept the driver for about 30 minutes. The driver came back to the car; I got in and thought we were going to leave. But they still had the key. A soldier said, OK you can leave, just give us some money to get something to eat. I gave him something. Without looking at it, he asked me how much it was. “350” I replied. “350 what?” “350 francs” (less than $1). “What can I eat for 350 francs?” Some pondu (manioc leaves), some good fufu, even a piece of fish. But I don’t think he was looking for dining suggestions. So, then he asked for a $100, but I did not laugh at him. I explained, again, that I was a professor, that I am not especially wealthy (though compared to him I am), that I am in Kinshasa teaching Congolese students, and that I don’t live in the (rich) area (although where I live is extremely comfortable). He explained to me that they were not just regular police, but the Presidential Guard, and that the President was asleep and that I might wake him up. He then asked if we had anything to drink.

At this point, it had been more than 30 minutes. They had the keys, so I got out of the car again. I decided to call for someone to work this out. They told me to shut off my phone--which I didn’t do (though I didn’t make the call then). Then they took the driver away again, and, I later learned, threatened to beat him up. I got out of the car, and I called for some assistance. The soldiers came over and told me to put the phone away; I ignored them. And after about 3 or 4 minutes, they let us go. Nobody had to come. I knew that they emptied my driver’s wallet and was relieved that he wisely only had 1,000 fc in it. The encounter was, by all accounts, extremely mild to what folks experienced under Mobutu. The driver and my friend, who I was on my way to pick up (and who found himself waiting a bit longer than expected), were laughing and talking about how much better things have gotten. Under Mobutu, the driver would have been taken to jail, probably held for ransom. Nowadays, that is less common.

Thankfully thankfully thankfully my friend and I were on our way to a terrasse to have a drink. After the encounter, I wanted the beers a bit too much. I drank 2 Skols (beers that come in large 72 cl bottles, the size of 2-3 US bottles) quickly, and woke up Sunday morning with a headache. But, I realized, episodes like that can make a person drink. I suspect the soldiers realized it as well.

lundi, avril 24, 2006

At the Institut National des Arts

On Friday I gave a presentation of my research at the Institut National des Arts (INA) at the invitation of a Professor of Theater. The topic of my talk, which was entirely in French, was “The Influence of Bakuba Art in the United States.” The audience of about 40 people was split between students and professors, some of whom are affiliated with the sponsoring center, CEDRA (Centre d’Etudes, Documentation, et Recherche sur les Arts). The school, which is located in a former hotel, has 1,000 students in three departments--theater, music, and arts administration. (The third category accounts for 70% of their enrollment, much to the chagrin of the creative folks I met.)

To show the images, I have a powerpoint presentation on my laptop, and borrowed a projector and screen from the US embassy. The INA building is pretty limited in terms of electricity, if not ingenuity. The electric supply in the room consisted of two stray wires hanging out of the ceiling. Someone then connected a standard outlet to these wires, which I then connected to the embassy’s extension cord and projector, and voilà. We were in business.

My presentation was largely about visual art--specifically the influence of Hampton University’s Bakuba collection on artists in the US. Since I knew the artistic background of the audience was a bit different, I spoke a little bit of the history of African music and other performances at Hampton (such as pageants from the 1910s to 1930s that featured the traditions of the school’s Kikuya, Ndau, Zulu students).

Many of the questions were ones I have been asked before--how do the artists who produced this work benefit from its esteem? This is a question without a satisfying answer. Even though its presence in Western museums theoretically enhances the selling price of many pieces, it remains clear that the large majority of artists and communities are not making money. I know that the Bakuba are now trying to sell a royal costume to bring electricity and running water to the capital city of Mushenge; the king asked for my help (which says something about how desperate they are). There was a question about repatriation, which, as I replied, it is a question for the Congolese people to decide. Governments and museums should honor this decision. Stolen and sacred objects should be returned. This is clear. It seems to me that there needs to be other solutions as well, based of what artists, their descendents, or the national councils want. I’d like to propose a few possibilities. The US, in conjunction with museums, could donate American masterpieces to African museums. Actually, this could be done in terms of long-term loans, and the status of African works “owned” by US museums actually be converted to a similar status of “long-term loan” in which financial compensation is provided to the artist (or her descendents) if identifiable, or otherwise to the community (in the forms of schools or infrastructure). I am glad that there are opportunities to see African art in the US, even though the provenance of these objects is part of a profoundly tragic history. Clearly there needs to be reparations.

The case of the Sheppard Collection at Hampton, which I study, is unique. There is substantial evidence that Sheppard did not wantonly pillage. (For example, the most valued objects he describes were not part of his collection but ended up in Belgium.) I don’t want to sound like an apologist. Because none of this should change the right of the objects to be returned. Hampton is not especially wealthy and does not charge admission, which means that there is limited revenue that could be shared.

Other equally provocative questions suggested that Bakuba music might circulate in the US in ways similar to the visual arts that I am documenting. This was an excellent question because Lucy Gantt Sheppard, who was a former Fisk Singer, spent nearly 20 years in Central Africa. After she returned to the US in 1910, she spent more than 40 years directing a Presbyterian Church choir in Louisville, Kentucky. I don’t know of any recordings of the choir; there may be sheet music (admittedly an unreliable indicator of live performance) that warrants study. I get great feedback from artists when I share my work with them.

After my presentation, I had a soda with some professors, and met the school’s artistic director (who does costumes and sets). She is a textile artist who works with raffia (palm), which makes it a cousin to the Bakuba textiles I discussed. She showed me some of her work, and gave me a lovely raffia cell-phone bag. Very nice. (I've received several compliments telling me it is très à la mode.) Along with one of the other women I met, she directs a puppet theater and showed me a couple of the marionettes, which were amazing. Kola nut heads, raffia hair and bodies. These were amazing. The theater professors do a bit of work with African American drama (often comparative work with other African Diaspora theater), and we discussed showing A Raisin in the Sun next month.

She also showed me some raffia embroidery that she was doing and offered to make me a US flag, which I vehemently, but politely and with explanation, declined.

mercredi, avril 19, 2006

Locked Out

I had been told that UniKin shuts the doors and locks out students who have not paid their tuition. When I first heard it, I did not realize it was literal. I thought it was a figure of speech. Even after I was told that it was literal, it was hard to believe.

On Monday morning when I arrived at my office, the door I usually use was locked. Occasionally this is the case; being Easter Monday I assumed a slow day was the cause. All of the other doors were locked too. But there were people inside of the building. I circled the building twice. I found an open door. Dead end. I asked some students, who told me to keep walking and that I would find an open door. Which I did. And in front of the door was a large group of students. As I approached, I realized the university had padlocked all of the doors and had security guards (surprisingly unarmed, at least at my building) requiring students to show their tuition receipts to enter the building. Apparently students wait until the last possible moment to pay their tuition, so the school does this to get their money. Without a receipt, there is no admission. It is really crazy. So I made my way to the door and I know one of the guards (plus I don’t look like a student or really anybody else at the university), and he made a path to let me squeeze through. I found out the following morning that I can come to my usual entrance and one of the attendants there will unchain the padlock for me. It is really a horrible way to treat people, and is a ridiculous and embarrassing system.

I was supposed to have class on Tuesday morning from 10:30 to noon with one student. At 12:15, I received the following text message on my phone:
I’m sorry. I was at the campus the gates were closed I didn’t have my tuition receipt to get in.

The class that she missed was an on Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy of the Oppressed (!)--I can’t make this shit up.

lundi, avril 17, 2006

Back to the Theater

When I described teaching Lorraine Hansberry’s play A Raisin in the Sun, I lamented that there were not more opportunities for students to see live theater. So when I found out that a colleague’s play was being performed downtown, I eagerly invited a couple of students to attend. Two of the three undergraduate literature majors (everyone else in our department is linguists) were eager to go, but the problem is transportation. There is no way of getting back to the campus by taxi or taxibus at 9 or 10pm on a Friday night. If they could find transport to Ngaba, it would take a couple hours from the theater (at that time, there are few vehicles and lots of passengers). Then they would have to walk up the hill from Ngaba to where they live, which would take well over an hour. One student had told me she wanted to go; I told her to invite the other, and I told them I would meet them at the theater (I had some other things to do during the day) and could take them home afterwards. They are both the daughters of professors and neighbors.

I didn’t do anything--but it was a really big deal for the students and I think they really appreciated it. One called me on Sunday to invite me to have Easter dinner with her family. I was not able to join them because I had another invitation, but it was very thoughtful.

The play was being performed as part of a festival “Yambi,” which will be traveling to Brussels next year. I saw two productions, both excellent. The first was Toréadors (by Jean-Marie Piemme), which was set in a laundry. It begins when a prospective patron in soiled clothes shows up five minutes before closing. Some extremely witty exchanges ensue, and a very touching odd couple friendship emerges that includes a Christmas Eve dinner. The play managed to offer some commentary on labor, economics, politics, and friendship. The highlight of the play was the troubadour, Jean Goubard (who the students tell me is a pretty popular singer), who performed these seemingly improvised and hysterically funny songs on an acoustic guitar in between scenes. He would riff on the final words of the previous act, which was always something like fonctionnaire (civil servant) or cuisse de poulet (chicken leg). Think Jonathan Richman in There’s Something About Mary.

The second play I saw was Le Remaniement (The Reorganization), which is written by a colleague at UniKin, Thierry Nlandu. It is a political satire and, like Toréadors, is a really effective balance of comedy and political commentary. It was performed by the same cast I saw do it a couple of months ago, and I enjoyed watching it again. In the interim, I read the play which helped since there is a lot of word play, puns, and its pace is quick which is challenging for me to follow in French (compared to the other play which gave me little trouble). Again, a full house and a nice evening.

I have been in Kinshasa six months now, and some things are starting to feel comfortable. At the theater, I knew a bunch of people--in addition to my students and colleague, there was the brother of a friend of a friend who I met a couple of months ago, a professor at another university who I met last month, someone who attended my Lire en Fête presentation back in October, etc. Still, on the ride home, as I discussed the play with my students, I think we were all grateful for my Nissan Sunny as we passed taxibuses (minivans) with people riding on the roofs. Even after six months, I find myself staring; it still does not feel familiar or comfortable.

jeudi, avril 13, 2006

My Television Debut

Last month, I had my television debut on RTNC, which is the state network here. I appeared on a program called, Midi Culture.

Actually, I was just tagging along with my Intended, who was the real television star for the afternoon. After her presentation of the film When We Were Kings about the 1974 Ali-Foreman fight in Kinshasa, the media requests for newspaper, radio, and television were piling up. So she was to be the guest on a cultural affairs talk show. As the good host I am, I accompanied her through a military contingent to the studio. Then, with a couple of minutes to “On Air,” I heard the producer saying, “Get a fourth chair on stage.” Uh. OK. I was not wearing a jacket or tie, and I hadn’t shaved in quite a while (because we didn’t have water at the house for a few weeks). Well, I buttoned the top button of my shirt at the suggestion of the host, and that was that. A couple of minutes later, I was live on television in the largest francophone city in the world.

The hosts were Florence, a young actor, and Bobina, a film professor at the Catholic university in Kinshasa. The questions were mainly to my Intended, about cinema in the US and her impressions of Kinshasa. Bobina was an impressive guy, and they had a nice conversation with her about cinema, spectatorship, and the production of images. A discussion that could have easily became a lament about the absence of film culture in Kinshasa really took shape as a constructive dialogue about what film culture is and can be, suggesting ways that it can be developed. Kudos to the participants.

Me, I was mainly a spectator. I smiled and nodded my head in agreement. But I looked good doing it…

samedi, avril 08, 2006

Settler Colonialism

A Belgian woman arrived at the Guest House last night at around 9pm. She was born in Kinshasa in 1957; her father was an executive at Unilever. Her family returned to Belgium in 1960 when Congo became independent. This is the first time she has been back. This is her husband’s first visit to Congo as well. His great-grandfather, whose letters are still in his family, joined the Force Publique, the Belgian colonial occupation militia, in 1888.

Pretty much every Belgian person has similar personal connections to Congo. At independence (and I may have already put this information on the blog), there were more than 100,000 Belgians in Congo. This was about 1% of the Congo’s population, and even a larger percentage of Belgium’s population. If there were 100,000 here at that moment, the number of Belgians who had spent time here was even higher. The white population was concentrated in a relatively small number of regions and neighborhoods; it was an apartheid system. People here still point out to me the neighborhoods where they were not allowed after sundown. It is not unlike Miami Beach up through the 1960s.

This morning I showed my graduate students, Apocalypse Now Redux, which is the restored version of the original. It was the first time I have seen this version. One of the added scenes has Willard (Martin Sheen) and his crew showing up at 70-year-old French colonial plantation in the middle of North Vietnam during the US war. The family, which is defending the plantation with arms, welcomes the Americans as “allies.” (Nonetheless, their tally of those they have killed includes six Americans.) After being asked, “Why do you stay here?” a settler, himself unable to understand the US’s interest, eventually replies, “It belongs to us.”

jeudi, avril 06, 2006

Presidential Candidates and Others

I am posting an article that appeared in the New York Times about two weeks ago when Kofi Annan was in town, and will give an update below.
March 26, 2006

Congo, With Iraq in Mind, Faces Voting and Threats

BY MARC LACEY

KINSHASA, Congo, March 23 - One of the angry young men marching through the streets here in the Congolese capital the other day carried a handwritten sign that summed up this country's worst fears. "Tshisekedi," it said, "or Iraq."

The sign was a threat directed at Congo's government: meet the demands of Étienne Tshisekedi, a veteran opposition politician, or face the wrath of his unruly band of supporters in the Union for Democracy and Social Progress, who are known for their aggressive ways.

"Without Tshisekedi in this election, there will be civil war," said Diudonne Mulumba, one of several thousand marchers in support of Mr. Tshisekedi.

Congo, battered by almost unimaginable civil strife, is approaching its first nationwide elections in nearly half a century with a mixture of optimism and outright fear.

It is not only the troublemakers who are bringing up Iraq, a country where elections were billed as a savior but seem to have done little to quell violence. Even those preparing for Congo's own milestone, those eager to introduce democracy to a country that has known only strongman rule, invoke Iraq's lessons as the election in June draws near.

Events in Iraq have made it clear to many here that elections alone do not unite divided countries, despite the poignant scenes of long-oppressed people lining up at the polls.

And while the Iraqi elections were considered a significant logistical challenge given that country's insecurity, bitter sectarian divide and lack of democratic tradition, Congo is in an entirely different league of difficulty.

"Compared to the Congo, Iraq's elections were a walk in the park," said Ross Mountain, the United Nations official who helped run Iraq's elections and is now organizing a similar operation in Congo, a country more than five times as large, more than twice as populous - with scores more tribes and languages - and relatively few usable roads.

Mr. Mountain rattles off the many nightmarish difficulties he faces: getting ballots to remote villages, protecting voters from armed men who still prey on them and encouraging onetime warring parties to compete and, if the results do not go their way, to accept defeat.

The day of reckoning is June 18 - unless, that is, the date to elect a president and members of Parliament is postponed a third time.

The last day for candidates to file papers was Thursday, but that deadline was pushed back a week in an effort to draw the numerous parties that are boycotting the process into the mix, including the part of Mr. Tshisekedi (pronounced chee-seh-KEH-dee) who has served in numerous Congolese administrations but gains most of his popularity by provoking from the outside. "We are militants," said Mr. Mulumba, a Tshisekedi advocate. "We are proud to be militants. Our combat is against dictatorship. We fight for democracy."

Kofi Annan, the United Nations secretary general, swept through Congo this week trying to ensure that the elections do not reignite the nation's old conflicts. So there he was in his hotel room with Mr.
Tshisekedi, urging him to join the race.

Mr. Tshisekedi, who did not immediately respond to Mr. Annan's pleas, is but one of dozens of potential candidate threatening to boycott the polling and discredit what they see as a sure victory for Joseph Kabila, the 34-year-old military commander who took over the presidency when his father was assassinated in 2001.

As part of a 2003 peace deal, Mr. Kabila has the job temporarily while four vice presidents representing Congo's divided political landscape check his power. Mr. Annan met with all five men, encouraging anyone with political aspirations to do the same thing: join the race.

But some are already writing off the elections as a sham.

"This is a rigged election," said Kabamba Mbwebwe Kabuya, who had planned to run for president under his Patriotic Front party but was stymied by the $50,000 fee required of candidates. "How can you call it a democratic election when everyone knows who will win?"

No one knows for sure, because opinion polls are nonexistent and most people have never voted before. But Mr. Kabila, who formally entered the race this week, has the power of the state behind him, and analysts suggest that the only way he could face trouble is if opposition parties merge.

Congo has 250 or so political parties, some of them actual organizations, some bands of militants and some little more than grandiose names. But despite a penchant among the people to debate their country's political failings, Congo has precious little experience with orderly transfers of power.

Leaders traditionally grabbed power here and stayed until they die, sometimes of unnatural causes. The last time the Congolese chose their leader was at independence in 1960.

This year, voters will have choices, although perhaps not as many as they would like.

One choice, Diomi Ndongala, who was fired by Mr. Kabila as mining minister amid corruption allegations, is spinning his presidential bid as a way to clean up government.

"If I broke the law, they should charge me," he said, declaring himself to be the poorest mining minister this country, with its long history of official looting, has ever seen.

"We must change the mentality of people in Congo," he said. "They can't think they can take power by arms."

Mr. Annan had a similar message as he encouraged Congo's powerbrokers to put statesmanship above personal ambition. "With elections in many countries that are coming out of conflict, if you don't have an inclusive election and try to use the process as a unifying force and try to get people to reconcile, just having elections won't do it," he said.

But getting everyone involved proved far more tricky than Mr. Annan may have imagined. Mr. Tshisekedi remains on the outside, insisting that Mr. Kabila's government meet his demands, including reopening voter registration to allow more of his backers to sign up.

The fear is not that outsiders will just denounce the election results but that they and their followers will work to challenge them. In Congo's past, that has meant violent confrontation and, sometimes, civil war.

The United Nations' largest peacekeeping mission in the world, with 17,000 troops, is already in the country and available should violence break out as the election nears. A separate European Union force of about 400 soldiers is due here before the vote to act as a rapid response force. An additional 1,000 or so European Union troops will be on standby outside the country.

The trouble spots are many: in eastern Ituri Province, where ruthless militias still operate; in the Kivus and Katanga, areas where a combination of rogue government soldiers, traditional fighters and Rwandan refugees wreak havoc on local populations; in the cities, where demonstrations are sometimes met with a fierce official response.

The United Nations has made significant headway in luring fighters to give up their guns or join the national army, but some say they are frustrated that the country, with its economy in shambles, offers them few ways of making a living.

An election is meant to be a turning point, and this one surely will. Until the 2003 peace deal, the country was divided into rebel fiefs. It is now one Congo, albeit a troubled one where more people die of conflict-related deaths - from violence or preventable diseases - than in Sudan's Darfur region or in Iraq.

"We can wait until everything is perfect but how much time will that take?" Mr. Annan said. "One year,
two years, three years?"

The decision to plunge ahead with elections has been made, but Mr. Annan, perhaps again learning something from Iraq, said the peacekeepers who will referee the polling will stick around for the aftermath.

Copyright 2006
The New York Times Company

Last week, someone (who wasn't there) told me that there were close to one million UDPS supporters in the street, not the "couple thousand" reported by the Times. I have my doubts about both sets of figures, but it is revealing that folks here are talking about 1,000,000 people outside of the MONUC headquarters.

The Electoral Commission gave prospective candidates ten additional days to register. UDPS demanded that voter registration also be reopened for previously boycotting party members. The Commission said no, and Tshisekedi is not among the candidates for President. He does have support here in Kinshasa and in Kasai. Seventy-three candidates registered to run for President (including two sisters!), though only about half actually paid the required $50,000 fee, probably narrowing the field to between 35 and 40 at last unofficial count. About five are considered serious contenders though a lot will be determined by the alliances that develop. The extension of the registration deadline will probably delay date of the elections, currently set for June 18; there should be official word on the new date in a couple of weeks.

In addition to meeting with Annan, President Kabila met over the weekend with Jendayi Frazer, the US Assistant Secretary of State in charge of African Affairs. Frazer was Condoleeza Rice's dissertation student at Stanford, and more recently US Ambassador to South Africa. To the best I can tell, she didn't really offer much of substance, other than to encourage him to stay the course with elections and to support military reintegration. I suspect the US is probably pretty confused by the situation, and is hedging its bets and hoping for something they can recognize as stability.

lundi, avril 03, 2006

St. Canisius Library at Kimwenza

Last week I finally made it to the library of a nearby seminary at Kimwenza, about which I had heard some good things. There is not much in terms of libraries on campus, though there are some efforts to improve the situation. I genuinely like the history professor who has recently been put in charge of the university libraries, which makes me optimistic. (His daughter is one of my best students too.)

A six-month library card for St. Canisius Library at Kimwenza can be had 2000fc (slightly less than $5). After you pay the fee, they take your picture with a digital camera and print out a real library card. I don’t know of anyplace else here that does this. It is a research library, which means the books do not circulate, but the reading rooms are so comfortable, I wouldn’t want to read them anywhere else anyway. The reading room compares favorably to my campus office, which is in the basement with bad light. While I appreciate the energy on campus, the noise and traffic at the university can be distracting.

St. Canisius has a computerized catalog, and five workstations where you search for a title. Patrons, mostly seminarians and other students, fill out a request slip, and someone retrieves the book for you. For my own research, its holdings are pretty good, not great. Their materials are a bit denominational, meaning mostly Catholic, which is only surprising because I found the holdings of another nearby seminary library affiliated with the same order to be remarkably non-denominational. My research is on the work of Americans in Congo, which, in terms of religion, means Protestant missionaries. But, not surprisingly for a Catholic country, the best libraries are run by the Catholics.

There was one extraordinary book I came across, prepared by a Belgian priest, Father Bontinck, who was a history professor here and who ran the more secular Catholic library that I mentioned. He compiled an anthology of materials from American archives about Leopold II’s Etat Indépendant du Congo. Most of the material in this collection relates to Henry Shelton Sanford, a scoundrel of the first order, who was the US delegate to the 1884-1885 Berlin Conference while secretly on Leopold II’s payroll as a lobbyist. The Bontinck volume is a sourcebook of materials that includes many documents that I had trouble tracking down in the US (even though they should all be in US archives). The book has a section on historian George Washington Williams who came to the Congo in 1890 and was one of the first outspoken critics of Leopold’s regime. Williams, who is the subject of a wonderful biography by John Hope Franklin that includes some of this same material, traveled to the Congo anticipating many collaborative projects with the State. But these letters reveal that as he was preparing for his departure, he began to meet severe opposition from Sanford and some of the Belgian concession companies operating there. As Williams wrote to Sanford,
If the Congo is what you have claimed it to be, there need be no uneasiness about travelers visiting it on their own account; I am now, as ever before, a true friend of the State of the Congo but I shall discharge my mission without fear or favor and if anything should happen to me, you will be held responsible.
Seven months later, after seeing the territory firsthand, he changed his assessment. In an 1890 letter to Secretary of State (and sometime Presidential candidate) James G. Blaine, Williams wrote,
The State of Congo is in no sense deserving of your confidence or support. It is actively engaged in the slave trade and is guilty of many crimes against humanity.
(I am struck by his use of the phrase “crimes against humanity”; I wonder when this phrase was first used, by whom, and in what context.) In addition to this letter, Williams wrote a series of pamphlets which were condemned by Belgian parliamentarians, ministers, and US diplomats--all of this, significantly, more than a decade before the organization of the Congo Reform Association brought international attention to Leopold’s brutal misrule.